Thanksgiving is a time for gratitude, gathering, and indulging in the quintessential flavors of fall. And what’s Thanksgiving without a perfectly baked pie? If you’re in Chicago and wondering where to preorder the best Thanksgiving pies, you’re in luck. The Windy City is brimming with bakeries, patisseries, and restaurants offering delicious pies to elevate your holiday feast. From classic pumpkin and pecan pies to innovative flavors that reflect the city’s culinary creativity, we’ve compiled the ultimate guide to help you find the perfect pie for your celebration.
1. Why Preorder Your Thanksgiving Pie in Chicago?
Thanksgiving is one of the busiest holidays for bakeries, and pies are the star dessert of the season. Preordering ensures:
- Guaranteed availability: Avoid last-minute stress and disappointment if your favorite pie sells out.
- Custom options: Many bakeries offer customizations for preorders.
- Freshness: Your pie will be baked fresh for your pickup date.
2. Classic Pie Flavors You Can’t-Miss
Whether you prefer sticking with tradition or exploring bold flavors, Chicago’s bakeries have something for everyone. Popular flavors include:
- Pumpkin Pie: A Thanksgiving classic with a creamy pumpkin filling spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.
- Pecan Pie: Rich, nutty, and decadently sweet, often made with a splash of bourbon for a Southern twist.
- Apple Pie: A comforting favorite with a flaky crust and spiced apple filling.
- Sweet Potato Pie: A silky alternative to pumpkin pie with a distinctively earthy flavor.
- Cranberry Pie: A tart and sweet choice for those who want something different.
3. Top Spots to Preorder Thanksgiving Pies in Chicago
Bakeries
1. Hoosier Mama Pie Company
- Why It’s Popular: Known for its traditional yet elevated takes on classic pies.
- Best-Selling Pies: Pumpkin pie, honey vinegar pie, and chocolate chess pie.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: Typically a week before Thanksgiving.
- Pickup Locations: Chicago (West Town) and Evanston.
2. Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits
- Why It’s Popular: Rustic pies with a focus on high-quality, locally sourced ingredients.
- Best-Selling Pies: Salted chocolate pecan, key lime pie, and pumpkin pie.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: Orders open mid-October and close a week before Thanksgiving.
- Pickup Locations: Logan Square and Ravenswood.
3. First Slice Pie Café
- Why It’s Popular: A socially conscious bakery that gives back to the community.
- Best-Selling Pies: French silk, apple crumble, and pumpkin.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: 5-7 days before Thanksgiving.
- Pickup Locations: Andersonville, Ravenswood Manor, and Evanston.
4. Vanille Patisserie
- Why It’s Popular: French-inspired pies and tarts with a sophisticated touch.
- Best-Selling Pies: Pumpkin tart, pecan pie, and chocolate mousse tart.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: November 17.
- Pickup Locations: Lincoln Park and Chicago French Market.
5. Sweet Mandy B’s
- Why It’s Popular: Nostalgic desserts with a homemade feel.
- Best-Selling Pies: Apple pie, pumpkin pie, and pecan pie.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: November 20.
- Pickup Location: Lincoln Park.
Restaurants Offering Thanksgiving Pies
6. Beatrix
- Why It’s Popular: Modern, health-conscious takes on classic flavors.
- Best-Selling Pies: Pumpkin chiffon pie and caramel pecan pie.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: 5 days before Thanksgiving.
- Pickup Location: Fulton Market, River North, and Streeterville.
7. Publican Quality Meats
- Why It’s Popular: Known for its artisanal approach to everything, including desserts.
- Best-Selling Pies: Maple pecan and spiced pumpkin.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: November 19.
- Pickup Location: West Loop.
8. The Bristol
- Why It’s Popular: Seasonal pies crafted with local ingredients.
- Best-Selling Pies: Apple cranberry pie and chocolate pecan pie.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: 1 week before Thanksgiving.
- Pickup Location: Bucktown.
Specialty Stores
9. Eataly Chicago
- Why It’s Popular: Italian-inspired desserts perfect for adding a unique twist to your table.
- Best-Selling Pies: Ricotta tart and pumpkin cheesecake.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: November 20.
- Pickup Location: River North.
10. Bennison’s Bakery
- Why It’s Popular: A North Shore staple for over 80 years.
- Best-Selling Pies: Dutch apple, pumpkin pie, and pecan pie.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: November 18.
- Pickup Location: Evanston.
11. Gene’s Sausage Shop and Delicatessen
- Why It’s Popular: Eastern European delicacies with a selection of seasonal pies.
- Best-Selling Pies: Plum pie and sour cherry pie.
- Details:
- Preorder Deadline: November 19.
- Pickup Location: Lincoln Square.
4. Tips for Ordering Thanksgiving Pies
- Order Early: Many bakeries close preorders by mid-November.
- Check Pickup Times: Ensure you’re available during designated pickup hours.
- Consider Storage: Some pies may need refrigeration, so plan accordingly.
- Double-Check Ingredients: If you have dietary restrictions or allergies, confirm the pie’s ingredients.
- Reheating Tips: Ask for reheating instructions to serve your pie warm and fresh.
5. FAQs About Thanksgiving Pies in Chicago
1. When should I preorder my Thanksgiving pie?
Most bakeries start taking orders in October and close preorders 5-7 days before Thanksgiving. Order early to secure your spot.
2. Can I get gluten-free or vegan pies?
Yes! Many bakeries, such as First Slice Pie Café and Bang Bang Pie, offer gluten-free and vegan options.
3. Are there delivery options for Thanksgiving pies?
Some bakeries and services offer delivery. Check directly with the business or explore third-party delivery platforms.
4. What’s the average cost of a Thanksgiving pie in Chicago?
Expect to pay $25-$50, depending on the size, ingredients, and bakery.
CONCLUSION
This Thanksgiving, let Chicago’s talented bakers and chefs take care of your dessert needs. Whether you’re a pumpkin pie purist or someone seeking an innovative flavor, the city offers an array of options to satisfy every palate. Preorder early to ensure a stress-free and delicious holiday celebration.
Ready to place your order? Don’t wait—secure your Thanksgiving pie today and make this year’s feast unforgettable!
In another related article, Best Tips for Budget-Friendly Christmas Holiday Travel